Welcome to Tomato Joe's New York Pizzeria
TOMATO JOE’S NEW YORK PIZZERIA brings real New York-style pizza to Tampa. Located at 7032 W Waters Ave, we serve fresh, authentic pizza every day. Our menu has classic favorites like cheese and pepperoni, plus specialty options. You can grab a quick slice, take food home, or enjoy delivery straight to your door. Great pizza is easy to get here.
Fresh Ingredients, Great Pizza
Our pizza starts with fresh dough, house-made sauce, and high-quality toppings. Each pizza is crafted with care, from classic slices to specialty pies. The menu also includes salads and sandwiches, all made with the same fresh approach. Every meal is made to order and ready to enjoy, hot and fresh.
Easy Ordering, Your Way
Ordering from TOMATO JOE’S is fast and simple. You can place your order online or call ahead for takeout or delivery. The system makes it easy to choose your favorite pizza and add extras. Your order is prepared quickly and ready when you want it, giving you a smooth and convenient experience every time.
New York-Style Pizza and More
See our fresh New York-style pizzas made daily. From classic slices to specialty pies, every dish is made with care and quality ingredients.
Catering for Any Event
Ordering from TOMATO JOE’S is fast and simple. You can place your order online or call ahead for takeout or delivery. The system makes it easy to choose your favorite pizza and add extras. Your order is prepared quickly and ready when you want it, giving you a smooth and convenient experience every time.
Dine In with Comfort and Speed
Our restaurant is clean, fast, and friendly. Stop in to enjoy your pizza in a welcoming environment. We make service simple, so you can relax and enjoy your meal without delays. Perfect for family dinners, a quick lunch, or catching up with friends, our space is designed for comfort and convenience.
What our guests are saying
I love this place. Very clean, great employees, pizza was perfect and on this day I got the great deal of 2 large slices of pizza and can soda special, after working up an appetite shopping at Tampa Thrift Store. Perfect day of eating & shopping on Labor Day 2025.
Kimberly K.
I highly recommend the Tori's wings, the cheese fries and the Little Cuban pizza (I get that without the chicken on it). The Balboa with steak is also great. Whether it's eating in, taking out or delivered the food is always fresh and hot and delicious. Best wings and cheese fries I've ever had and one of the best pizzas I've had too.
Heather C.
I’m visiting Tampa from New York and I was searching for a pizza place that offered real authentic pizza. This was the place that looked the most authentic based on pics and reviews, and I gotta say… the pizza here blew expectations. This is true, authentic, NY style pizza. From the moment I picked it up from the restaurant, I could tell from the smell alone that this place was legit. The pizza was perfect. The dough is hand made too. 10/10. When I next visit Tampa again, I have no reason to try out a different place.
Farhan H.
Featuring
Catering
Delivery
Takeout
Dine In
Tomato Joe's New York Pizzeria Rewards
Join our rewards program, earn points every time you order online and redeem your points for free food!
Frequently Asked Questions
What are you known for?
We are known for Garlic Knots, Meatballs, Cheese Bread, Greek Salad, Pizza Bianca, Spaghetti, Calamari, Salads, Pasta, Chicken Parmesan, Caesar Salad, Cheesecake, Lasagna, Buffalo Chicken Pizza, Mozzarella Sticks, Calzone, Chicken Wings, Stromboli, White Pizza, Wings, Pepperoni Pizza, New York Italian Restaurant, Cheese Pizza, and Veggie Pizza
Where are you located?
We are located in Tampa, FL at 7032 West Waters Ave
What areas do you serve?
We serve the following areas: Town 'n' Country, Tarpon, Rocky Creek, Egypt Lake-Leto, Citrus Park, Carrollwood, Mullis City, Westchase, Northdale, Cosme, Lake Magdalene, Oldsmar, Drew Park, Keystone, University, Plaza Terrace, Nowatney, Safety Harbor, Harbor Palms.
Our location
